Don’t Grab The Hand When You’re Offered a Finger: On Selling
When the girl agreed to go out for dinner with me, I was over the moon. Not because I had a genuine fondness for her but because after texting her for days, I felt like I was finally able to make my first "sale" — a date.
Call me naïve but I thought that if she agreed for a first date, the second was a no brainer. Over the course of dinner, I casually kept nudging her to make up her mind to see me again.
“I perform improv comedy on stage. We should hang around more if you want to get in some laughs for the day”, I would say. I painted too positive an image of myself. I was trying hard to seem likeable. I kept selling the idea about what it's like to be with me.
The girl agreed for one dinner but I turned a simple dinner interaction into a hopeful prospect of being together. In other words, she offered a finger. I reached for the hand.
It doesn’t surprise me that she didn't want a second date. And if you are wondering ‘why?’, then read on.
People don’t like to be sold, but they love to buy
Jeffrey Gitomer, a salesperson and author said that buyers genuinely enjoy the experience of discovering something they want and choosing it on their own.
“When buyers feel understood, informed, and in control, the sale happens naturally — because it becomes their decision, not yours”, he said.
An American Express sales executive at the airport comes up to you and asks for a minute to speak to you about their latest credit card. You nod. You ask him about lounge access. Instead of simply answering that one question, he goes on and on trying to pull you in with new launches, reward-offers, travel perks, exclusive benefits — leaving the response to your lounge access question lost in a flood of attempts vying for your commitment.
You feel cornered. You are no longer interested.
Now imagine a different approach.
You ask him about lounge access. He keeps his response short and to the point. He notices you are running late and navigates you towards your boarding gate. He ensures if you need any further help, wishes you a safe flight and doesn’t mention the credit card again.
You walk away feeling relaxed. Because you weren’t pressured.
Weeks later, when you actually consider getting a credit card, who comes to mind?
The Wrigley's Ad
In the book ‘Stories That Stick’, the author Kindra Hall talks about a Wrigley’s chewing gum advert that took over the internet in 2015. Through this commercial, Wrigley wanted to promote its chewing gum. But the ad did not focus on the gum.
It focused on the emotionally touching story that the gum was quietly a part of.
The commercial follows a young couple from the moment the boy offers the girl a stick of gum. There’s no pitch about flavour or freshness. It’s a silent evolving love story. Each memory is marked by a gum wrapper the boy keeps. Years later, he proposes to the girl with those saved pieces of wrappers.
The gum is never sold in the commercial. The human story is.
Wrigley’s reported an estimated $85.5 million in incremental value sales after this campaign.
What this means for you
Don’t just start pitching. Many people talk like it's just the sale that matters. But what makes the sale happen is the human-to-human interaction, that is ideally not about the sale.
The key is to make the conversation free of outcome. Remove the pressure. Remove any desperation. Don’t make your listener feel trapped. Allow them room to trust you.
There's a name for what happens when you feel pushed into buying something. Psychologist Jack Brehm called it Psychological Reactance. The moment someone senses their freedom of choice is being threatened, they instinctively pull back. The sale doesn't just slow down — it reverses. The push creates the resistance.
5 Practical tips - Trust before transaction
We are in a constant state of selling — whether its a point of view, an idea, a product / service, or ourselves. But if someone has only offered a finger, here’s how you don’t grab the hand.
Ask one genuine question and actually listen. Not to lay out your next selling point but because you are genuinely curious. People can tell the difference between someone who is listening and someone who is waiting to speak.
Talk about them more than you talk about yourself. A simple rule of thumb is let others speak 70% of the time. The less you talk about yourself, the more interesting you become.
Earn the hand, don’t assume it’ll be given. Whether she agreed to dinner or whether the prospect took your call, honour that moment for what it is i.e a finger, not a hand. Each step of trust is earned separately.
Help without expectation. Like the American Express executive at the airport. Do one thing for them that has absolutely nothing to do with what you want. That gesture will be remembered more than any pitch.
Notice what they care about and remember it. People don't remember what you said. They remember how you made them feel. Stop obsessing over the perfect words. Start obsessing over whether the person in front of you feels heard, valued, and understood.
In conclusion
The best conversations and the best sales happen when you stop thinking about the outcome and simply show up for the person in front of you.
The girl didn't want a second date because I was too busy selling myself to actually be present and enjoy each moment of interaction with her. I was so focused on the hand that I forgot to appreciate the finger that was offered.
Comments